Last updated: Apr 15, 2025

Betting the NHL

Introduction

The goal of this page is to help the recreational hockey better. I carefully look at the value of the major ways to bet -- the money line, over/under, and puck line, to determine the best value. Then I list some miscellaneous hockey statistics for your entertainment.

Data and Methodology

The following data is from every game played in the four NHL seasons starting with the 2017/18 season. The total number of games played in these four seasons is 4,875. It is worth noting that the 2020/2021 season was shortened to 1,904 games due to the Covid pandemic.

The data was purchased from Big Ball Data one season at a time. The first three seasons had very tight lines that I presume came from Pinnacle Sports. The fourth season had more normal 20-cent lines. In evaluating the expected returns below, I calculated overall returns for all the data and then used the appropriate weighting factors to get the returns to equal the 4.54% expected with a 20-cent line, which the vast majority of sports books offer for hockey.

The next three sections show my analysis of the three major ways of betting hockey -- the money line, over/under, and puck line.

Compare Online NHL Odds

Ice Hockey HockeyAllsvenskan

Ice Hockey NHL

Ice Hockey NHL Championship Winner

Ice Hockey SHL

Money Line

Money Line bets are simple bets on who will win. The following table shows the expected return flat betting all underdogs, favorites, and picks (both teams have 50/50 chance of winning). As expected, based on studying other sports, the underdogs offer a better value, with a house edge 2.73% less than better on favorites.

Money Line Bets in the NHL

Bet on	Expected Return	House Edge
Underdog	96.82%	3.18%
Favorite	94.09%	5.91%
Pick	95.45%	4.55%
Total	95.45%	4.55%

Of the 4,875 games in the last four seasons studied, the home team won 2,627 (53.9%) and the road team was 2,248 (46.1%). The next table breaks down how money line bets went both ways.

Money Line Bets in the NHL

Bet on	Expected Return	House Edge
Road	94.82%	5.18%
Home	96.09%	3.91%
Total	95.45%	4.55%

Over/Under

The next table looks at bets against the total. Not surprisingly, bets on the under did bet, with a house edge 1.67% than bets on the cover. This does not come as a surprise, because bets on the under do significantly better than the over in every sport I have studied.

Over/Under Bets in the NHL

Bet on	Expected Return	House Edge
Over	94.62%	5.38%
Under	96.29%	3.71%
Total	95.45%	4.55%

Puck Line

The Puck Line is like the Run Line in baseball. It is a point spread that is always 1.5. The favorite always gives up 1.5 goals and the underdog gets them. The following table shows that the house edge betting on the underdog is 1.61% lower than betting the favorite.

Puck Line Bets in the NHL

Bet on	Expected Return	House Edge
Underdog +1.5	96.26%	3.74%
Favorite -1.5	94.65%	5.35%
Total	95.45%	4.55%

I should mention I spent a lot of time studying puck line bets, looking to see if there was any value assuming the money line bets were fair. To make a long story short, I find the sports books do a good job in setting the puck lines properly.

Ohio Recommended Online Sports Books

View All

75 % up to

750$

Play Read Review

100 % up to

500$

Play Read Review

50 % up to

250$

+100 spins

Play Read Review

50 % up to

250$

+100 spins

Play Read Review

Fun Facts

The following table shows the average goals scored by period and overtime for both regular season games and the playoffs.

The reason I think they should be considered separately is there is an incentive to go to overtime in regular season games. To be specific, if a game is decided after three periods, then two points are awarded to the winner and zero to the loser. However, if the game is decided in overtime, two points are awarded to the winner and one to the loser. Overtime is always sudden death (team to score first wins). The data shows the probability of overtime in a regular season game is 22.57% and drops to 20.89% in the playoffs.

Average Goals by Period

Period	Regular Season	Overtime	Combined
1	1.7260	1.5300	1.7106
2	2.0100	1.9530	2.0055
3	2.0151	1.9008	2.0062
Overtime	0.2257	0.2089	0.2244
Total	5.9768	5.5927	5.9467

The following table shows the probability of all viable number of goals scored per period for a single team.

Number of Goals per Team by Period

Goals	Period 1	Period 2	Period 3
0	42.02%	36.04%	37.08%
1	37.01%	37.84%	35.67%
2	15.59%	17.94%	19.22%
3	4.39%	6.50%	6.22%
4	0.81%	1.41%	1.56%
5	0.17%	0.24%	0.23%
6	0.01%	0.03%	0.03%
7	0.00%	0.01%	0.00%
Total	100.00%	100.00%	100.00%
Average	0.8553	1.0028	1.0031

The following table shows the probability of all viable number of goals scored per period for both teams combined.

Number of Goals per Team by Period

Goals	Period 1	Period 2	Period 3
0	17.68%	12.80%	12.21%
1	30.75%	26.38%	26.87%
2	26.77%	28.35%	28.33%
3	15.77%	18.65%	19.43%
4	6.58%	9.39%	8.88%
5	1.78%	3.16%	2.81%
6	0.51%	0.82%	1.15%
7	0.06%	0.37%	0.29%
8	0.06%	0.08%	0.04%
9	0.02%	0.00%	0.00%
Total	100.00%	100.00%	100.00%
Average	1.7106	2.0055	2.0062

The following shows the number of goals scored by the home team across the road team for the four seasons beginning with the one that started in 2017.

Number of Goals by Home Team across Road Team

Home Goals	Road Goals
Home Goals	0	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	Total
0	0	40	46	88	61	20	9	0	0	0	264
1	51	0	214	129	178	70	23	10	4	1	680
2	49	227	0	334	151	130	41	18	2	0	952
3	96	168	336	0	278	96	56	18	7	0	1055
4	68	180	191	274	0	128	24	20	2	0	887
5	32	97	223	89	106	0	34	6	4	0	591
6	11	44	56	93	38	35	0	5	0	1	283
7	6	25	20	31	20	7	6	0	0	0	115
8	2	2	10	6	7	6	2	1	0	0	36
9	1	1	2	4	2	0	0	0	0	0	10
10	0	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2
Total	316	786	1098	1048	841	492	195	78	19	2	4875

The following shows the number of goals scored by the winning team across the losing team for the four seasons beginning with the one that started in 2017.

Number of Goals per by Winning Team across Losing Team

Winning Team	Losing Team
Winning Team	0	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	Total
0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
1	91	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	91
2	95	441	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	536
3	184	297	670	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1151
4	129	358	342	552	0	0	0	0	0	0	1381
5	52	167	353	185	234	0	0	0	0	0	991
6	20	67	97	149	62	69	0	0	0	0	464
7	6	35	38	49	40	13	11	0	0	0	192
8	2	6	12	13	9	10	2	1	0	0	55
9	1	2	2	4	2	0	1	0	0	0	12
10	0	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2
Total	580	1375	1514	952	347	92	14	1	0	0	4875

The following table shows the number the count for each margin of victory and the probability for the four seasons beginning with the one that started in 2017.

Margin of Victory

Margin	Count	Probability
1	2,069	42.44%
2	996	20.43%
3	1,095	22.46%
4	451	9.25%
5	172	3.53%
6	71	1.46%
7	14	0.29%
8	4	0.08%
9	3	0.06%
Total	4,875	100.00%

The following table shows various statistics per game for road and home teams as well as the total between the two.

Miscellaneous Statistics — Road vs. Home

Description	Road Team	Home Team	Combined
Shifts	384.95	379.46	764.41
Shots on goal	30.56	31.87	62.43
Shots missed	11.36	12.16	23.52
Shots blocked	14.34	13.90	28.24
Assists	4.68	5.16	9.84
Points*	7.47	8.22	15.70
Penalties	3.58	3.34	6.92
Penalty minutes	8.47	7.92	16.40
Hits	22.37	23.29	45.66
Take aways	6.32	7.97	14.29
Give aways	7.95	10.56	18.52
Faceoffs won	28.42	29.93	58.35
Faceoffs lost	29.93	28.42	58.34

The following table shows various statistics per game for regular season and play offs games as well as the total between the two.

Miscellaneous Statistics — Regular Season vs. Playoffs

Description	Regular Season	Playoffs	Combined
Shifts	759.22	825.24	764.41
Shots on goal	62.40	62.79	62.43
Shots missed	23.48	23.95	23.52
Shots blocked	27.92	31.91	28.24
Assists	9.88	9.34	9.84
Points	15.76	14.93	15.70
Penalties	6.85	7.77	6.92
Penalty minutes	16.16	19.18	16.40
Hits	43.74	68.15	45.66
Take aways	14.28	14.39	14.29
Give aways	18.32	20.89	18.52
Faceoffs won	58.29	59.09	58.35

Notes:
*: A point is different from a goal. Points may be awarded to players assisting in a goal. The ratio of points to goals in the NHL for the four seasons starting in 2017 is 2.64.

The following table shows the ratio of goals to shots on goals cut various ways.

Ratio of Goals to Shots

Category	Ratio
Away	9.29%
Home	9.75%
Regular season	9.58%
Playoffs	8.91%
Total	9.52%

Top 6 Online Sports Book Bonuses

10Bet Casino Africa

Cashable

100% up to
R3000

New customers only. T&C's apply. 18+. Min Deposit: R20. The bonus can be used on Sports, Games, or Live Dealer. If you withdraw your funds before completing the bonus rollover requirements, any bonus amount and winnings from the rollover made using bonus funds will be lost.

min WR: 8xB&D

Wager the Bonus & Deposit amount 8 times on Sports Betting to Cashout.

Claim

BetFred Casino

Cashable

£50

New Customer Offer. T&C’s Apply. 18+. #ad New customers only. Register (excl 05/04/25), deposit with Debit Card, and place first bet £10+ at Evens (2.0)+ on Sports within 7 days to get 3 x £10 in Sports Free Bets & 2 x £10 in Acca Free Bets within 10 hours of settlement. 7-day expiry. Eligibility exclusions & T&Cs Apply.